National Key Lime Pie Day is Sept. 26! Here’s Where To Celebrate

Yes, we know that you’ve already kissed many of your favorite summer foods goodbye to make way for fall treats such as apple cider doughnuts, pumpkin pie and walnut cake. However, you don’t have to say sayonara to key lime pie yet – National Key Lime Pie Day is coming up on Sept. 26!

If you’re a key lime pie fan, there are plenty of places to get this sweet staple here on the Upper West Side. To finally kick your craving, check out these local eateries serving it without going too far from your Sagamore apartment.

Peacefood Café, located at 460 Amsterdam Ave, New York which is an eight minute walk from your Sagamore apartment, is a homey spot for raw and vegan sandwiches, juices, teas and desserts, plus daily dinner specials.

All of Peacefood Café’s desserts are freshly prepared and baked in their in-house kitchen, and they are also egg and dairy free. Check out their key lime pie with young coconut, cashew, avocado agave lime filling in an almond brazil nut crust!

Fairway Market Upper West Side, located at 2131 Broadway, New York which is a four minute drive from your Sagamore apartment, features a grab-and-go selection of upscale prepared foods attached to a sprawling gourmet grocery store.

Since the 1930s when their doors first opened, Fairway Market has been committed to bringing their customers excellent values, wide varieties, and the freshest foods, including a delicious key lime pie that always hits that sweet spot!

Peacefood Café

460 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024

(212) 362-2266

Fairway Market Upper West Side

2131 Broadway, New York, NY 10023

(212) 595-1888