Thanks To These Local Bakeries, You Can Bring the Perfect Pie This Thanksgiving

Of course, you can’t show up to Thanksgiving dinner empty-handed. However, you don’t necessarily have to slave over your Sagamore stove, either! The perfect addition to your Thanksgiving dinner is a homemade pie, but don’t worry – you can leave the baking to the experts.

If you want to bring a pie to Thanksgiving that your fellow guests will rave about, check out these bakeries located near your Sagamore apartment. And don’t worry… no one has to know that you didn’t lift a finger!

Little Pie Company, located at 424 W 43rd St, New York which is nine minutes from your Sagamore apartment, is a no-frills bakery specializing in scratch-made pies in three sizes, plus cakes, cookies and muffins.

Since 1985, the Little Pie Company has offered delicious pies in a neighborhood joint where bakers are framed by large picture windows, creating a warming, rustic slice of Americana. Locally sourced ingredients go into season-fresh pies, cakes and cookies and carefully considered fillings made from nature’s ripe bounty are poured into hand-pinched crusts before the tempting treats are placed into small batch steel ovens.

Magnolia Bakery, located at 200 Columbus Ave, New York which is seven minutes from your Sagamore apartment, is a down-home destination for classic baked desserts including pies, plus a variety of creative cupcakes.

From its inception, Magnolia Bakery has been cherished for its classic American baked goods, vintage decor and warm, inviting atmosphere. Patrons are also invited to place pickup orders for select products through their online store. They also offer nationwide shipping for a variety of products.

Little Pie Company

424 W 43rd St, New York, NY 10036

(212) 736-4780

Magnolia Bakery

200 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10023

(212) 724-8101

Satisfy That Sweet Tooth on Thanksgiving Day With These Local Pie Shops

Thanksgiving is coming up on Thursday, Nov. 22, and we’re all ready for the big feast full of turkey, stuffing, mashed potatoes and cranberry sauce. However, for those with a sweet tooth, there’s an even better part of Thanksgiving – dessert!

Thanksgiving desserts typically are full of pies in every variety, including apple, pumpkin and blueberry. Luckily for us on the Upper West Side, our area is full of tasty pie shops, which will certainly come in handy after you’ve already spent hours cooking Thanksgiving dinner!

If you want to keep your guests happy after the main meal is over on Thanksgiving Day, then make sure you stop by these bakeries well before the big day. Hurry though, they’re taking orders as soon as possible!

Margot Patisserie, located at 230 W 74th St, New York which is a six minute drive from your Sagamore apartment, is a charming French cafe known for their pies, pastries, savory plates and espresso, located in the venerable Ansonia building.

Margot’s pies are heavily influenced by Southern French cooking with unique recipes and techniques that are passed down to bakers and chefs at Margot. Plus, their team continues to innovate and come up with creative recipes of our own that are exciting to any palate.

Milk Bar, located at 561 Columbus Ave, New York which is a six minute walk from your Sagamore apartment, is a snug bakery known for their for quirky, inventive desserts from pastry chef Christina Tosi.

Their most famous pie is their crack pie, which has a toasted oat crust and gooey butter filling. Of course, this bakery is known for loads of other innovative desserts that are sure to satisfy any sweet tooth!


Margot Patisserie

230 W 74th St, New York, NY 10023

(212) 721-0076


Milk Bar

 561 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10024

(212) 256-0586